BenQ W10000

After a bit of a scare today, I managed to get the tracking on my new BenQ W10000 projector. Sure enough, FedEx brought it, but was running late today. Whew! Of course I wasted no time. I grabbed the box and headed for my dungeon (or theater, whatever you want to call it).


Be careful when grabbing one of these, they are about 35 lbs. shipped weight, and a bit bulky. I opened up the box, took out the projector and remote, and hung it onto my ceiling. For those who are unfamiliar with this unit, it is the latest offering from BenQ. It is a 1920x1080p DC3 DLP projector that retails for $8999 (with MAP at $5999). This makes it the least expensive 1080p DLP offering on the market. The unit uses an 8 segment color wheel (RGBRGB + 2 Dark Green ND) to help reduce rainbow effect as well as help with dithering in low light scenes. The unit has a 250 watt lamp but is capable of a 200 watt setting in one doesn’t need the full output. It has the standard gamut of inputs, including HDMI, S-Video, Composite, Component and RGBHV (also can be a second component). The throw on the unit tested out at a 1.77x-2.05x screen width. It also has lens shift for more flexible installation capabilities. The unit is capable of about 23db operation noise, which is about average by today’s standards. One of my favorite parts of the BenQ line is the remote control. This uses the same one as the PE8720, and is extremely well laid out. It is backlit, and has direct access to each input making macro programming easier. You also have quick access to such features as contrast and brightness for on the fly changes. The optics on this unit are extremely good. I was able to zero in the focus such that the individual pixels were extremely crisp (no fuzziness at all). There was also very little chromatic aberration with this unit.

 

- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -

     

 

The first thing I did was to calibrate the projector. I plugged in my signal generator and setup my probe. I zero’d all the factory settings and set the color temp to Normal. After running through the basic contrast and brightness adjustments, I tested the grayscale. Out of the box it was about 8196k (x=.283 and y= .333). This is not uncommon with BenQ I have found. They need a decent amount of adjustment out of the box to get them to NTSC standards. I went into the service menu and started my adjustments. I was able to get from 100 to 50IRE adjusted well, but at 40IRE it started to spike upwards. No matter how much I tried to adjust it in the service menu bias controls, I couldn’t get it flat. The red needed more, and as I adjusted it in the service menu, the measurement only went up slowly, but my background turned to an obvious redish tint. So I experimented and reset the service menu. I then went into the standard user menu and tried them there. Success! Here I was able to get the grayscale to track very well from 20IRE to 90IRE, with only slight spikes at 10 and 100 (not uncommon). I then went in and measured the primaries/secondaries. Here I was pleasantly surprised. The green and red were slightly oversaturated, but blue and cyan were spot on. Yellow and magenta were skewed a bit (yellow to green and magenta to blue), but with the 3D color adjustments I was able to get them all to the correct points.


After I was done tweaking the unit, I threw up some images. The first thing I did was HD DVD. I noticed was that the unit produced a very clean image. In fact, it almost didn’t look like DLP to me because there was very little noise in the image. However, this also made for a less crisp image that often is associated with DLP. Not to say the image wasn’t sharp, it just didn’t have the typical DLP look to it (take that for what it’s worth). In my preferred settings for iris and lamp (250 watt with iris about 90% to full), I found that the black levels very satisfactory and on par with what most current DLP’s have. It also had good brightness at this setting (I use a 103” diag. Vutec Silverstar and it was plenty bright). It is not by any means what I would consider a light-cannon, but for most theater applications with good light control, it can easily handle a 110”ish screen. If one desires a larger screen than that, or has ambient light to contend with, I would recommend getting a higher gain screen to help out in that regard, and possibly running the iris more open (again, sacrificing the contrast somewhat). The colors were very accurate with the reds being more crimson in color than orangish, and the green not having the typical limegreen color that DLP’s often do. This is partly helped with the 8 segment color wheel. I found saturation was a bit thin, and I found I had to increase the color adjustment a bit in order to get a richer, more colorful image. The unit has good shadow detail, I would say slightly above average for this level projector. The black levels weren’t buried at all either. The processing on the unit was better than I would expect. There was little edge enhancement, and it was able to handle about anything I could throw at it. I did attempt to plug my Dragonfly processor into it via 1080p60, but the BenQ wouldn’t take that signal through HDMI. It does take 1080p24sf, but not 1080p60 (at least through HDMI).

 


- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -


- Click To Enlarge -

 


- Click To Enlarge -


- Click To Enlarge -


- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -

 

   

 

 


- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -

- Click To Enlarge -
   

 

Measured Specs
As I mention in other reviews, I keep these to a relatively non-technical level. I find that though many are into the specs and measurements, not everyone has a good understanding, nor is even interested in the real technical stuff. That being said, I did take some measurements for those who are interested. Remember, my room is not an ideal setup for measuring. So the projector is really capable of better results in a perfect testing environment. Rather my results are what you might expect to get in a typical theater when properly setup. The below numbers are calibrated (D65) results as well.

 

On/Off Contrast (IRIS Minimum/250watt Lamp Mode):
On/Off Contrast (IRIS Maximum/250watt Lamp Mode):
ANSI Contrast (IRIS Minimum/250watt Lamp Mode):
ANSI Contrast (IRIS Maximum/250watt Lamp Mode):

Brightness (IRIS Minimum/200watt Lamp Mode):
Brightness (IRIS Maximum/250watt Lamp Mode):
Brightness (IRIS Minimum/200watt Lamp Mode):
Brightness (IRIS Maximum/250watt Lamp Mode):

X Value Before Calibration:
Y Value Before Calibration:
X Value After Calibration:
Y Value After Calibration:
Color Temperature Results:

Prefered Settings for Testing:
IRIS set to roughly 90% (5 clicks to left of full closed),
Lamp at 250watts.
On/Off Contrast:
Brightness:

~1317:1
~3900:1
~417:1
~564:1

553 lumens
686 lumens
144 lumens
193 lumens

.283 (target .313)
.333 (target .329)
.313 (target .313)
.329 (target .329)
6486k (target 6480k)




~2845:1
286 lumens

 

Conclusion
The BenQ W10000 projector is yet another offering in the 1080p market we are seeing grow. One of the biggest advantages is the fact that it is the lowest priced 1080p DLP on the market, bringing that technology level to a point more people can afford. It offers lots of adjustment capabilities, good contrast, sharp optics with flexible installation, and great build quality. All in all, for those who prefer the DLP technology, but are also looking for good value, this is one to definitely consider in your search.

Thanks!

Home  |  Products  |  Reviews  |  Showroom  |  Testimonials  |  Warranty / Returns  |  Installation  |  About Us   |  Contact Us  |  AVS Forum

Copyright  ©  2006 AV Science, Inc. - All Rights Reserved